
When a Chinese Factory Subcontracts Your Order: How to Detect and Prevent It
Subcontracting is not illegal in China, but undisclosed subcontracting is how specifications, materials and your money quietly change hands. The contract clauses, audit rights and red flags that keep your order where you placed it.
Buyers usually discover subcontracting the wrong way — the goods arrive with a different factory's stamp on the carton, the quality drifts, or a delay gets blamed on a “partner plant” nobody mentioned. Chinese law has no blanket ban on a manufacturer subcontracting production; whether it is allowed comes down to what your contract says. That makes the contract your main lever, and it makes detecting and preventing unauthorized subcontracting a matter of clauses, audit rights and a handful of tell-tale signs.
Know the legal frame: subcontracting is a contract issue
Two rules in the PRC Civil Code (合同编) do most of the work. Under Article 523, where performance is rendered by a third party, the original debtor — your supplier — remains liable for breach if the third party fails or performs non-conformingly. Under Article 551, a debtor may transfer an obligation only with the creditor's consent, and silence is treated as refusal. In practice the boundary between the two matters: mere performance assistance keeps your supplier liable, while an attempt to hand the whole order to another factory as a substitute obligor requires your consent. Ambiguous wording is typically read as the first, which is why an explicit no-subcontracting clause matters.
Put the clauses in writing before the order
The contract should make unauthorized subcontracting a defined breach, not an implication. The clauses that matter:
- No-subcontracting without prior written consent, naming the agreed factory and production site.
- The right to audit the factory and any sub-supplier, with access to production and quality records.
- A specification lock — frozen drawings, materials, components and testing protocols that survive any change of production site.
- Liquidated damages for unauthorized subcontracting, plus the right to reject non-conforming goods.
- A requirement that any subcontracted portion be disclosed with the sub-supplier's identity before production begins.
On liquidated damages, note that PRC courts can adjust agreed damages that are grossly excessive relative to the actual loss (Civil Code Article 585), so they are a deterrent, not a guaranteed payout. The audit and rejection rights are usually the more effective tools in practice.
The red flags that give subcontracting away
Unauthorized subcontracting usually announces itself before the goods arrive if you are looking:
- Delivery is repeatedly “from the factory” but shipment documents show a different origin or a third-party freight address.
- The supplier asks to change the production site or “transfer the line to a sister plant” mid-order.
- Quality drifts after the first samples, or the supplier suddenly asks to relax a tolerance they previously accepted.
- The supplier cannot schedule an audit, or the factory you visit is smaller than the one that produced the samples.
- Cartons, labels or certificates carry a different manufacturer's name.
What to do when you find it
On discovery, act through the contract rather than cutting off communication. Demand immediate disclosure of the sub-supplier and a factory audit; inspect and test the goods against the locked specification; withhold acceptance and payment pending cure; and claim liquidated damages or actual losses where the breach is real. Keep the documentary trail — the disclosure notice, audit reports and test failures — because the practical remedy hinges on proving the breach and the loss, not just on knowing it happened.
Write the agreed production site into the contract, not just the supplier's name. A supplier who has agreed in writing to produce at a specific facility has a much harder time quietly moving your order — and you have a much easier breach to prove.
Subcontracting itself is not the crime; undisclosed subcontracting that changes where and how your product is made is the risk. Name the factory, lock the specification, reserve audit and rejection rights, and treat any unexplained change of site or origin as a stop-and-verify event. This content is general information and not legal advice; for a specific contract or dispute, consult a licensed lawyer.
Related guides
Verify a supplier now
Run due diligence on a Chinese supplier before you pay.
