
Short Shipments and Missing Quantities from Chinese Suppliers: Detecting, Documenting and Claiming
A short shipment is usually discovered at the wrong end of the supply chain. How to detect the missing quantity, document it with an independent survey, and claim under the CISG.
Short shipment β the container arrives and the count is short, or the boxes are there but the units are not β is the most common and most preventable China sourcing loss. The reason buyers lose these claims is rarely the law; it is that they discover the shortage too late, and document it with their own word instead of an independent record. Win these claims at two moments: before the container leaves the factory, and in the first hours after it lands.
Detect it before the container is opened
The cheapest and most reliable evidence is created before the goods move. Have an independent third-party inspector count the goods at the factory or warehouse and seal the container, and record the seal number. If you cannot inspect at load, at least demand a dated, signed packing list with box-level detail and a weighbridge certificate, then compare the gross weight at origin against the container's declared weight. At the destination, break the seal in front of an independent surveyor or, at minimum, photograph the intact seal and record the receiving count on the delivery note before anyone signs it clean. A clean signature on the carrier's delivery note is the fastest way to destroy your claim.
Document it so the claim survives
The claim lives or dies on a short evidence list. Collect all of it before you contact the supplier:
- The signed contract, proforma invoice and the packing list β showing the quantity the supplier promised.
- The independent inspection or loading report, with the counted quantity and the container seal number.
- The bill of lading and the delivery note, with any shortage noted at receipt.
- An independent survey report at discharge (a marine cargo surveyor or a registered inspection company), not your own warehouse count.
- Photographs of the intact or broken seal, the opened container and the actual cartons received.
- Your written notice to the supplier stating the shortage and reserving your rights, sent within the contractual or CISG notice period.
The legal claim: quantity is conformity under the CISG
Where Chinese sales law governs or the CISG applies β China is a CISG contracting state β a short delivery is a lack of conformity, not a separate small print. CISG Article 35 requires the seller to deliver goods of the quantity, quality and description required by the contract. The buyer's duties are timing duties: Article 38 requires examination within as short a period as is practicable, and Article 39 requires the buyer to give notice specifying the nature of the lack of conformity within a reasonable time after discovering it β and in any event within two years of handover, unless a longer contractual period was agreed. Miss that notice and the shortage claim is lost even if the shortage is real.
Recover the money
The remedies scale to the situation. For a short delivery the buyer may reduce the price (Article 50), require the seller to deliver the missing quantity (Article 46), or claim damages for any consequential loss (Article 74), including the extra cost of buying the shortfall elsewhere if the market price has moved. Where the seller shipped more than agreed, Article 52 lets you take or refuse the excess. Practically, the fastest recoveries come from deducting the shortfall from the balance or retention under the contract, then pursuing the difference β which is why a contract that holds back a balance until after discharge inspection is the buyer's best friend.
A supplier that pushes back on an independent count 'because we already counted it ourselves' is telling you how the shortage happened. Insist on a third-party count at load, and never sign the delivery note clean until the seal and the count have been checked. This content is general information and not legal advice.
Short shipment is a documentation problem more than a legal one. The buyer who inspects at load, seals the container, counts at discharge and sends a reserved-rights notice inside the CISG window will collect; the buyer who trusts the supplier's packing list and signs clean will not.
Related guides
Verify a supplier now
Run due diligence on a Chinese supplier before you pay.
