Iflawyer
Ask a Lawyer
…
← All guides·Legal Rights10 min read2026-10-12
Inspecting non-conforming goods received from a Chinese supplier

Non-Conforming Goods from a Chinese Supplier: Your Legal Remedies

The goods arrived wrong. Here is what CISG and China's Civil Code give you — rejection, price reduction, repair, replacement, damages — and the notice deadlines that keep those remedies alive.

The container arrives, you open it, and the goods are wrong — wrong colour, wrong grade, wrong quantity, or wrong in a way that only shows up in testing. The question most buyers ask first is emotional (how could they do this) when the question that matters is legal: what can I actually demand, and what do I have to do this week to keep those rights alive? Under the law that governs most China cross-border sales, the answers are specific, and the clock starts the moment you could have discovered the defect.

Which law governs: CISG first

For most international sales between a Chinese supplier and a foreign buyer, the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) governs automatically, because China has been a contracting state since 1988 and the CISG applies to sales between parties in contracting states unless validly excluded. That matters because the CISG rules differ in detail from domestic law. Article 35 requires the goods to conform in quantity, quality and description and to be fit for their ordinary or particular purpose; Article 36 makes the seller liable both for non-conformity existing at the time risk passes and for non-conformity that appears later due to a breach of warranty.

Fundamental breach: the key that unlocks rejection

Not every defect lets you send the goods back. Under Article 25, a breach is fundamental only if it results in such detriment that it substantially deprives you of what you were entitled to expect under the contract, and the seller could foresee that result. A fundamental breach opens the strong remedies: avoidance of the contract under Article 49(1), and delivery of substitute goods under Article 46(2). A non-fundamental breach leaves the softer but still real remedies — repair, price reduction under Article 50, and damages under Article 74. The classification is the first battle, and it turns on how central the defect is to the contract's purpose.

The Civil Code backstop

Where the CISG does not apply — because it was validly excluded, or the transaction falls outside its scope — China's Civil Code (民法典) supplies the equivalent framework. Articles 615 to 618 oblige the seller to deliver goods of the agreed quality and provide the default standards where quality was not specified. Articles 620 to 623 govern inspection and notice, and Articles 582 to 584 set out the remedies: repair, replacement, redoing, return, price reduction and damages. The remedies overlap heavily with the CISG list, but the deadlines and presumptions are worth reading in the Civil Code's own terms.

  • repair or redoing where the defect is fixable,
  • replacement or substitution where the goods are fundamentally wrong,
  • price reduction in proportion to the lost value,
  • return (rejection) of the goods with a refund,
  • damages for the loss actually suffered, including loss of profit that was foreseeable.

Notice: the deadline that kills claims

The single most expensive rule in the whole field is the notice requirement. Under CISG Article 39, the buyer loses the right to rely on a lack of conformity if it fails to give notice specifying the nature of the defect within a reasonable time after it discovered or ought to have discovered it — with an absolute cut-off of two years from delivery, unless that cut-off conflicts with a contractual warranty period. The Civil Code mirrors this in Article 621: inspect within the agreed period and notify within a reasonable time, capped at two years, with the quality-guarantee period overriding the cap and the seller's bad faith removing it. Reasonable time is measured in days or a few weeks, not months — so notice goes out immediately, in writing, with specifics.

Price reduction and damages: the maths

If you keep the goods, Article 50 CISG lets you reduce the price in the proportion by which the value of the delivered goods at the time of delivery falls short of the value conforming goods would have had. Damages under Article 74 cover your actual loss, including lost profit, limited to what the breaching party foresaw or ought to have foreseen at contract conclusion as a possible consequence of the breach. Where the parties fixed a liquidated-damages figure, Chinese law allows a court to adjust it if it is manifestly disproportionate to the actual loss — under the 2023 judicial interpretation on contract disputes (法释〔2023〕13号), a figure exceeding the actual loss by 30% is generally treated as excessively high.

Do not resell or process the goods first

One trap destroys otherwise perfect claims: using the goods. If you resell, process or put into production goods you later want to reject, the supplier will argue you accepted them, and the law often agrees that conduct can amount to acceptance or waiver. The exception is mitigation for perishable or dangerous goods, where you may act to limit loss but must document what you did and reserve your rights in writing. Keep samples, photograph everything at arrival, and commission an independent inspection — SGS, QIMA or a local equivalent — before the goods leave the port area.

💡 Time is the enemy, not the supplier

The defect is not your biggest risk; silence is. Send the written notice of non-conformity the day inspection fails, listing the contract number, batch, defect, evidence and the remedy you elect. A two-week-old notice still usually works; a two-month-old one usually does not.

Non-conforming goods are a legal problem with a clock attached: the remedies are generous, but every one of them can be lost by waiting. This content is general information and not legal advice; apply the CISG and Civil Code rules above to your specific contract and dispute with a licensed attorney, and confirm the latest official rules before relying on them.

This guide is general information for overseas buyers and is not legal advice. For a specific transaction or dispute, consult a qualified lawyer licensed in the relevant jurisdiction.

Verify a supplier now

Run due diligence on a Chinese supplier before you pay.

Verify now
⚖️Lawyer🤖AI Expert✉️Emailinfo@iflawyer.com