Iflawyer
Ask a Lawyer
…
← All guidesΒ·Legal Rights9 min read2026-10-12
A shipping delay and the force majeure clause in a China supply contract

Force Majeure and Delay Clauses in China Supply Contracts

When a Chinese supplier claims force majeure, the fine print decides who eats the delay. What force majeure really requires under Chinese law, and how to draft a delay clause that works.

Force majeure is the most abused phrase in international sourcing. A factory fire, a typhoon, a port backlog, a power cut, a 'policy change' β€” every missed shipment arrives with one of these attached, and the supplier's tone implies the law has already excused them. It usually has not. Force majeure and delay are governed by specific legal tests and, more importantly, by the clause you wrote. The difference between a protected delay and a supplier's free pass is almost always in the fine print.

What force majeure actually is under Chinese law

Under the Civil Code (民法典), Article 180 defines force majeure as objective circumstances that are unforeseeable, unavoidable and insurmountable, and provides that a party unable to perform because of force majeure bears no civil liability, except as otherwise provided by law. Article 590 adds the procedural half: the affected party must notify the other party in time to mitigate loss, and must provide proof within a reasonable period. Crucially, Article 590 also says the exemption does not cover liability for loss caused by delay that already existed before the force majeure arose β€” so a supplier already late before the typhoon cannot hide behind it.

Port congestion is not automatically force majeure

The test is foreseeability and unavoidability, not inconvenience. Routine port congestion, a raw-material price rise, a labour shortage during holiday season β€” these are commercial risks that a supplier in the trade is expected to bear, and Chinese courts generally treat them as such rather than as force majeure. Even COVID-19 was not a blanket excuse: courts examined each case on whether the specific epidemic-control measure actually prevented performance of the specific obligation. A supplier who asserts force majeure must show a causal chain between a qualifying event and the specific non-performance, not just point at a headline.

Changed circumstances: the adjacent doctrine

Beside force majeure sits Article 533, the doctrine of changed circumstances (ζƒ…εŠΏε˜ζ›΄). It applies where a fundamental change in the underlying circumstances β€” one the parties could not foresee, that is not a commercial risk, and that makes continued performance obviously unfair β€” allows renegotiation or a court adjustment or termination. It is deliberately narrow, and it is distinct from force majeure: force majeure is about performance becoming impossible, while changed circumstances is about performance becoming unfair. Suppliers frequently blur the two, because the second sounds more sympathetic; keep them separate and test each claim against its own standard.

Delay and liquidated damages

When a delay is not excused, the buyer's remedies run through the breach provisions. Article 577 gives the injured party the right to demand continued performance, remedial measures or damages. Article 585 governs liquidated damages: the parties may fix a sum for breach, and a court may increase or decrease it where it is manifestly disproportionate to the actual loss. Under the 2023 judicial interpretation on contract disputes (ζ³•ι‡Šγ€”2023〕13号), Articles 64 and 65, liquidated damages exceeding the actual loss by more than 30% are generally treated as excessively high β€” a standard worth remembering both when you draft a per-day delay rate and when a supplier challenges it.

CISG Article 79: the international standard

For international sales, CISG Article 79 supplies the exemption test: a party is not liable for failure caused by an impediment beyond its control that it could not reasonably be expected to have taken into account at contract conclusion, or to have avoided or overcome. The exemption lasts only for the period the impediment exists, and the party must give notice to the other side. Like the Civil Code, it is strict about the unforeseeability threshold β€” a supplier who signed a contract during a period of known disruption cannot later claim the disruption was unforeseeable.

Drafting a delay clause that survives

  1. Define force majeure narrowly, with named examples and explicit exclusions β€” port congestion, supplier-side labour disputes and raw-material price changes are commercial risks, not force majeure.
  2. Require written notice within a fixed number of days, with proof such as a CCPIT or CCIC force majeure certificate.
  3. Make suspension temporary, not automatic termination: performance resumes when the event ends, and the delay is not excused beyond the event's duration.
  4. Give the buyer a right to terminate after a fixed period of continuous delay, with a refund of the deposit.
  5. Fix per-day liquidated damages for delay, calibrated to your real exposure, and reserve the right to claim actual damages beyond the cap where law allows.
  6. State that force majeure does not excuse payment for goods already delivered and accepted.
πŸ’‘ Demand the certificate, not the story

The first response to a force majeure claim is the same as to a price-hike call: put it in writing and ask for proof. CCPIT issues force majeure certificates for qualifying events, and a supplier who cannot produce one is usually describing a commercial problem, not a legal one.

Force majeure and delay are decided by the clause you wrote long before the event, not by the supplier's email after it. This content is general information and not legal advice; apply the Civil Code and CISG principles above to your specific contract with a licensed attorney, and confirm the latest official rules and judicial interpretations before relying on them.

This guide is general information for overseas buyers and is not legal advice. For a specific transaction or dispute, consult a qualified lawyer licensed in the relevant jurisdiction.

Verify a supplier now

Run due diligence on a Chinese supplier before you pay.

Verify now
βš–οΈLawyerπŸ€–AI Expertβœ‰οΈEmailinfo@iflawyer.com