
China Supplier Change Orders and Mid-Production Modifications: Documenting Them So You Don't Pay Twice
Under the CISG a contract can be changed by mere agreement β unless the contract requires changes in writing. How a no-oral-modification clause works, what a change order must record, and why China's 2013 withdrawal of its Article 96 reservation matters.
Mid-production changes are where China orders quietly lose money. The buyer asks for a tweak, the factory agrees over a call, production continues, and six weeks later the invoice has a 'modification charge' nobody agreed to β or the buyer rejects goods that were changed exactly as discussed but never written down. The law that decides who wins is the CISG, and its default is not what most buyers assume. This guide explains how changes become binding, why a no-oral-modification clause is the single most useful line in the contract, and what a change order must record.
The CISG default: changes need no writing
Most China purchase contracts are governed by the United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG). Article 29(1) of the CISG provides that a contract may be modified by the mere agreement of the parties β no writing is required, and a change agreed orally or by conduct can bind both sides. That is the trap: the buyer believes an undocumented tweak is a favour or a suggestion, while the law may treat it as a binding variation. Article 29(2) is the escape hatch β if the contract itself provides that modifications must be in writing, the writing requirement prevails and the parties cannot vary the contract orally. The practical consequence is that a single sentence in the contract flips the default.
China's Article 96 withdrawal and why it matters
There is a second layer that used to confuse people. China is a CISG contracting state and had once lodged a reservation under Article 96 requiring contracts to be in writing. China withdrew that reservation, with effect from 1 August 2013, so the CISG's form-freedom default β including Article 29(1)'s rule that modifications need no particular form β now applies to contracts between parties in China and other contracting states, unless the parties validly exclude the CISG or agree their own form requirements. For a buyer today, the takeaway is concrete: you cannot rely on a general assumption that changes must be written down; you have to put that requirement in the contract yourself.
The no-oral-modification clause is your shield
A no-oral-modification (NOM) clause states that any variation must be in writing, and ideally says what counts as 'in writing' β an email from a named address, a signed change order, or an exchange through an agreed system. The clause does not ban changes; it disciplines them, so a WeChat voice note from a salesperson does not become a contractual variation. It also forces the commercial conversation into a form you can file, which is exactly the point when the dispute is about what was agreed.
What a change order must record
- The exact change β the specification, drawing, material, quantity or packaging being altered, tied to a revision number.
- The price impact β the increase or decrease, stated as a number, not 'to be advised'.
- The schedule impact β the new delivery date or lead time, and who bears any expediting cost.
- The cost of scrap and tooling β who pays for work already done that the change discards.
- A confirmation that all other terms are unchanged β so the change order does not accidentally reopen the whole contract.
Who can bind the supplier
A change order is only as good as the authority of the person who agreed to it. A salesperson's WeChat message can be electronic evidence under Chinese law, but the dispute usually turns on whether that person had authority to bind the company β so the contract should name who is authorised to approve changes, and every change order should come from (or be confirmed by) that person. The buyer has the mirror problem: changes requested by a junior buyer that management later disowns are just as binding on you if the contract lets them be.
The checklist
- Put a no-oral-modification clause in the contract, and define what counts as 'in writing'.
- Name the people authorised to agree changes on each side.
- Issue a written change order for every variation, with price, schedule and scrap cost stated as numbers.
- Confirm the change order is accepted in writing before work on the change begins.
- File the change orders against the original purchase order so the final invoice can be reconciled line by line.
A supplier that quotes a 'modification charge' at the end of a job is almost always pointing at an oral change nobody wrote down β and under CISG Article 29(1) that oral change can bind you. The fix is a no-oral-modification clause enforced in practice: every change in writing, with its price and schedule impact stated, before the work changes. Related reading: China Purchase Order Essentials, and China Supplier Quality Agreement Clauses.
Change orders are where a well-run order and a costly dispute part ways. Put the no-oral-modification clause in the contract, name the authorised signatories, and document every variation with its price and schedule impact in writing. The buyer who does this pays once; the buyer who does not pays twice. This content is general information and not legal advice.
Related guides
Verify a supplier now
Run due diligence on a Chinese supplier before you pay.
